Assignment #3 - The Board (Feedback 09)

All but 2 assignments have been graded.  You should have by now received a note from me with your grade, how I arrived at it and some personal feedback on your paper.

Overall, the class met or exceeded my expectations:

Grade range:  9.0 - 14.1 / 15
Grade average: 11.6 / 15

Here are some overall thoughts and feedback:

  • In Part 1, I was looking to see good academic research and analysis.  Top grades went to papers where specific references were cited (e.g. looked for several definitions of what a board was and should be) and where there was absolute clarity as to the differences between types of boards and what makes a good board.
  • In Part 2, I was looking to see that you applied the best practices you learned from Part 1 in your team project (e.g. interviewed their board members for expectations, noted how and why they selected their board members, etc.) 
  • make it easy for me to grade your paper!  Given a subject line of "paper" and no hard copy, it is tough for me to grade your paper and more probable that I will misplace your paper.  (Same applies to all of your classes.)  A couple students lost minor grades unnecessarily for this.
  • Note:  As per our discussion in class, Part 1 was an individual effort and was where I focused the grading.  Part 2 was intended to help you move your team project along and to give me the opportunity to provide a bit of coaching where needed.  I was looking to see that teams were communicating what they learned in Part 1 and were applying this to their projects